All hat, no jurisdiction

The U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, Aaron Reitz, has been busy, but not in the usual way. He’s been sending letters to members of Congress involved in Democratic plans to renew oversight of the executive branch come January. They are “preservation letters,” directing the legislators to preserve documents, etc., “relevant to your intention to weaponize congressional investigations” and referencing criminal statutes Reitz suggests they may be violating.

None of the members of Congress are in his district. Congressman Robert Garcia (California), Senator Richard Blumenthal (Connecticut), Senator Elissa Slotkin (Michigan), and Senator Elizabeth Warren (Massachusetts) have all received letters from Reitz.

Title 28 U.S.C. § 547 defines the responsibilities of United States Attorneys. They prosecute crimes. They defend the United States when it gets sued and bring affirmative civil lawsuits when appropriate. They collect money judgments on behalf of the United States. But each U.S. Attorney can only do that “within his district” according to the statute. Absent a designation by the Attorney General to take up a matter in another district, for instance, because the U.S. Attorney there must recuse themself, they lack jurisdiction to prosecute crimes committed outside of their district.

The Judiciary Act of 1789 reinforces that point. It created the position of Attorney General and U.S. Attorneys, who were to serve in districts across the country. It requires the appointment, in each district, of a “person learned in the law to act as attorney for the United States in such district, who shall be sworn or affirmed to the faithful execution of his office, whose duty it shall be to prosecute in such district all delinquents for crimes and offences (sic), cognizable under the authority of the United States, and all civil actions in which the United States shall be concerned.” Again, that language appears, not once, but twice: “in such district.”

The notion that U.S. Attorneys lack authority to act outside of their district was recently underscored in Jeffrey Epstein co-conspirator Ghislaine Maxwell’s appeal of her criminal conviction. She argued that she was protected from prosecution in the Southern District of New York by a plea deal Epstein entered into years earlier in the Southern District of Florida. That plea agreement purported to prevent further prosecution of additional defendants. The Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit held that a deal entered into by the U.S. Attorney in the Southern District of Florida didn’t bind U.S. Attorneys in other districts. That’s because, put simply, U.S. Attorneys’ power to investigate and charge is limited to crimes they have jurisdiction over in their district.

In his letters, Reitz invoked two federal crimes: civil rights violations. I’ve worked extensively with those statutes. Even without the First Amendment and Speech or Debate protections that would interfere with the government’s ability to prove its case here, the conduct Reitz is upset about doesn’t amount to a crime. For one thing, the “mens rea,” or state of mind, the prosecution must establish beyond a reasonable doubt is willfulness, which courts interpret as a specific intent to deprive someone of a federally protected right. In a letter sent to Senator Warren, Reitz accuses her, along with Blumenthal and Garcia, of “demanding sweeping information” from a private citizen—which is pretty much how investigations work. There’s no legitimate inference that the legislators are committing crimes; in fact, the suggestion in this context is ludicrous.

Reitz doesn’t appear to have the authority to back up his threatening letters. If the Attorney General had designated him to investigate, that would be an official matter, and it would be public, like when Attorney General Bill Barr designated Connecticut U.S. Attorney John Durham with investigating the origins of the Russia probe following the 2016 election. That hasn’t happened, at least not yet.

Reitz also doesn’t have the resume you’d expect for someone taking on matters like this; Durham, by contrast, was an experienced prosecutor. Reitz served as the head of DOJ’s Office of Legal Policy—as the name suggests, a policy shop, not a litigating division—and as Ted Cruz’s chief of staff. He’s spent some time in private practice, but he doesn’t have the years of expertise in prosecution it takes to handle a complicated matter, which a criminal investigation into four sitting members of Congress engaged in their official duties would certainly be. That lack of experience shows; prosecutors have the ultimate tool for obtaining information from people under investigation, grand jury subpoenas, at hand. There’s no need to resort to preservation letters. The letters feel more like a political ploy than a legitimate prosecutorial strategy. In any other administration, you’d be shocked to see the attorney general designate him to handle matters like this outside of his own district. But here, we’ll just have to wait and see.

Today, The Campaign for Accountability, a public watchdog organization, submitted a grievance against Reitz to the Texas Bar based on his letters to Blumenthal and Warren.

Reitz has caught Trump’s attention, with the president reposting his tweets on Truth Social. Like the one below. “My first arrow shot.” As a former prosecutor, I have questions. “My first arrow shot?” How many is he going to need to get it right? The sprinkling of Native American terms in the letter is beneath the dignity of a sitting U.S. Attorney. In any other administration, it would have resulted in a request for a resignation. Now, it earns the president’s approval.

Reitz’s letters close with a demand for a response from each of the legislators. Their lawyers will likely counsel professional responses; Senator Blumenthal has already sent an appropriately dismissive one. But part of me hopes the four are familiar with the response letter sent by then-Alabama Attorney General Bill Baxley, in response to a letter he received in February 1976 from a grand dragon in the Ku Klux Klan. The letter expressed outrage that Baxley had reopened the investigation into the bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham that killed four girls getting ready to attend services. The writer demanded a response. Baxley’s letter back was a classic: “Dear ‘Dr.’ Fields,” he wrote, “My response to your letter of February 19, 1976, is — kiss my ass.”

How did we get here? Start with Reagan.

How did we get to the point where an unforced error — it wasn’t weather, it wasn’t a terrorist attack, it was simple incompetence — could inflict so much damage on a rich, technologically advanced nation? To use the old line: Gradually, then suddenly.

According to federal officials, the immediate cause of the problem was a failed router upgrade at a remote radio facility in Arkansas, combined with a so far unexplained issue at a radar facility in Amarillo, Texas. So far there is no specific reason to doubt this story, just the fact that Trump officials lie about everything. But in any case, the real question is not the specifics of what happened Friday but how a basic federal function like air traffic control could have deteriorated to the point where minor, local problems could bring the whole system crashing down.

Remarkably, the sudden disruption of air travel was a disaster foretold. Just two months before the ground stop, the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office warned that the ongoing effort to modernize air traffic control was a rush job that was all too likely to go wrong…

And sure enough …

…But why are the FAA’s systems so outdated? And I mean outdated: The agency is planning to phase out floppy disks by 2028.

The answer is that the FAA isn’t unusual. In the U.S., government at all levels — federal, state and local — runs on outdated software and hardware, with legacy systems basically held together with paper clips and rubber bands. During the Covid crisis, as states scrambled to provide temporarily enhanced unemployment benefits, we learned that many states were still administering benefits using systems running on COBOL, a programming language introduced in 1959.

This reliance on antiquated technology isn’t because government workers are stupid. It’s because for many decades they haven’t been given the resources to upgrade their equipment. America used to have a government that invested in the future. But ever since Ronald Reagan declared that “…government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem”, critical government functions have been starved of funds for investment…

…And then came DOGE. DOGE utterly failed in its promise to reduce federal costs by trillions of dollars and, in fact, it almost surely worsened the budget deficit by, among other things, slashing the number of IRS auditorsand hence undermining tax collection. Elon Musk and his gang of twentysomething vandals did, however,manage to fire or drive out an astonishing 13 percent of the federal work force in a matter of months.

These drastic job cuts weren’t based on careful evaluation of which jobs could safely be eliminated, based on consultation with experts who actually knew how government agencies worked. Instead, the Muskovites came in with an attitude of arrogant ignorance: They knew nothing about the agencies of which they became temporary overlords, but believed themselves to be so much smarter than the people working at those agencies that they didn’t need to check with those people before wielding their chainsaws.

In the end, they disrupted many essential government functions, and in some cases agencies scrambled to rehire the workers who had been laid off.

Did DOGE help cause the air travel disaster? My guess is that we’ll eventually find out that it did, but we’re just beginning to piece together exactly what happened.

What’s already clear, however, is that DOGE’s attitude of arrogant ignorance was central to the FAA modernization program. That GAO report makes it clear that there were strong reasons to worry that the program was being rushed without adequate thought or consultation. It’s also clear that Duffy and his subordinates ignored these warnings, presumably believing that whoever was advising them was smarter than all those timid experts and bureaucrats — those who had survived the DOGE cuts.

The idea that a random rich guy and some twentysomething incels could blunder in and immediately eliminate the fraudwasteandabuse they assumed comprises most government spending with no relevant expertise was both incredibly damaging in itself and reflects much deeper Republican ideas about government, ones that Trump himself was unhinged enough to fully implement. Underfund infrastructure and fire essential employees with no process, and days like Friday are going to keep coming across many sectors.

Let’s say it again: The Nvidia “honeypot” story is bullshit. It was all Trump graft and corruption

The Honeypot Was A Cover Story: Everyone In Trump’s Nvidia Scandal Was In On The Payday

 

The spy story was the cover. The real one is a president, a Commerce Secretary and a CEO all working in tandem, getting paid off the same AI chips. And it’s about to go thermonuclear.

For two weeks, Washington has been selling you a spy thriller. Poor Jensen Huang, the leather-jacketed genius of American AI, seduced by a Chinese temptress who batted her eyelashes until 240,000 banned chips fell off the back of a truck. It’s a great story if you’re Jensen, because it makes him a victim. It’s a great story if you’re Howard Lutnick, because it makes him merely asleep. And it’s a fantastic story if you’re Donald Trump, because nobody asks what the president had riding on it.

There was no honeypot.

There was no entrapment of an unwitting innocent.

There was pre-planned collusion.

Jensen Huang and Alice Huang worked together to get around export controls, they worked with Lutnick and Trump, everyone was putting $$$$ in their pockets, China was getting chips, and that the word for it is conspiracy.

In TrumpWorld, the buck stops with Biden

In Trump-world, nothing is ever his fault. Indeed, nothing can be his fault. The MAGA articles of faith do not permit an outcome in which Trump bears responsibility for anything negative, no matter how tightly tied to Trump’s incompetence and corruption. Trump’s favorite scapegoat for all things presidential is Joe Biden. The knee-jerk response of Trump and his surrogates to blame Biden is so pervasive that it has become an internet meme. The reflexive impulse to blame Biden is a measure of Trump’s moral failing as a leader.

President Harry S. Truman had a wooden sign on his desk that said: “The buck stops here.” Trump’s version reads, “The buck stops with Biden.”

As the nation reels from a nationwide ground stop of commercial flights last Friday, Trump blamed the Biden administration for unexplained router overloads in Arkansas and Texas.

After 48 hours of silence on the nationwide shutdown, Trump’s first comment was posted at 5:35 a.m. on Sunday:

 

Trump’s long silence was unusual and suggests that the administration is still attempting to (a) figure out what happened, (b) cover up the truth, or (c) both. No matter. The truth will out.

Why does any of this matter? Because the national ground stop negatively impacted tens of millions of Americans. They are angry, upset, and want answers. They want to know whether air travel is safe. They expect Trump and his administration to provide clear, honest, and timely answers. Trump’s first post met none of those expectations.

Moreover, all Americans instinctively understand when someone is trying to dodge responsibility—and most of them intensely dislike that behavior.

49 days remain before the 120th Congress convenes on January 3, 2027. During that interval, Republicans will attempt to leverage their expiring majority to confirm judges, pass legislation, and fund the government. A weakened, mockable Trump will motivate congressional Democrats to challenge him more vigorously; conversely, congressional Republicans will be less likely to extend themselves for someone perceived as a weak leader who refuses to take responsibility for events on his watch.

Moreover, more than 48 hours after the ground stop, the administration is playing “hide the ball” with the root cause of the failure. Instead, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy is pointing to the final link in the chain of causation that led to router overloads, while saying that the government is still investigating the underlying cause. See NYTimes, Duffy Points to Router in Arkansas as Start of Nationwide Ground Stop.

Per the NYTimes,

But [FAA] investigators still have not determined whether a faulty part or an error on the part of L3Harris, which owns the telecoms system in question and is responsible for upgrading and maintaining it, caused the initial problem in Arkansas. And Mr. Duffy said they are equally unsure why the facility in Amarillo failed on Friday when no upgrade work was being done there at the time. [¶]

During an interview Sunday on NBC’s “Meet the Press,” [Secretary of Transportation Sean] Duffy said he could not guarantee that a meltdown like Friday’s would not happen again.

“First we have to figure out what happened,” he said, adding, “We’re going to figure out what was the root cause and then move forward from there, fixing how we do business at the F.A.A.”

As noted above, the FAA does not yet have an explanation for what happened, a fact that has not stopped Trump and Duffy from pointing fingers at Biden and prior administrations.

Some experts are expressing skepticism about the FAA’s explanation. See, for example, NYTimes, How Could a Router Lead to a Nationwide Ground Stop?

Per the Times,

“The idea that you would have a single router take down a national network is just not plausible,” said Robert W. Mann Jr., who founded an airline analysis and consulting firm. He expressed skepticism about the Transportation Department’s explanation.

See also, CNN, Some air traffic controllers “don’t buy” Duffy’s explanation for ground stop.

Per CNN,

Anna Giaritelli told CNN’s Laura Coates she had been in contact with 60 air traffic controllers and “none of them are buying what he said.” [¶]

Giaritelli said “these types of [upgrades] they’re doing . . . don’t happen during busy times like a Friday afternoon. They’re doing these [upgrades] midweek, middle of the night when there is no air traffic going on.”

Moreover, the nationwide ground stop occurred three days after the FAA announced a nationwide rollout of a new artificial intelligence tool to help route flights. Predictably, the developer of the software denied that its AI implementation had anything to do with the ground stop. Still, the two-day lapse between the national rollout of the AI software and the ground stop is suspicious. See Palm Beach Post, Was AI behind FAA groundstop? SMART air traffic software says no.

Per the Palm Beach Post,

The ground stop on Friday, Nov. 13 took place just days after the FAA announced it would expand an artificial intelligence tool to all nationwide air traffic control centers. [¶]

The timeline for implementation of the $875 million program began Sept. 21 in Washington and the FAA pushed up the nationwide deployment to Nov. 10

We will learn much more in the coming days and weeks. In the meantime, the refusal of the Trump administration to accept any responsibility for the ground stop and its inability (or refusal) to provide a complete, credible explanation of the root cause more than 48 hours later is deeply troubling.

The American people deserve better.

Looks as though we have the start of a rebellion in the Republican Party

Well, well, we’ve got a rebellion in the RNC!!

Kentucky’s KC Crosbie, the RNC’s second-in-command is trying to kick out current RNC Chair Joe Gruters.

Trump’s handpicked party chair faces a rebellion as midterm losses challenge president’s grip on GOP

NEW YORK (AP) — A nascent rebellion is underway against President Donald Trump’s handpicked chairman at the Republican National Committee, and it’s already getting ugly.

Some members (168) are calling for a forensic audit of spending decisions, including hair and makeup services for Trump and other officials, as well as the hiring of the daughter of Trump’s former chief of staff. Feuding Republicans are leaking emails and opposition research on rival factions. The White House is threatening to cut off fundraising assistance if the rebels don’t fall in line.

During a White House meeting Nov. 6, Trump threatened to punish the RNC if members crossed him and said he would refuse to help the organization, including appearing at fundraisers or allowing his name and image to be used in mail and digital solicitations. That’s according to a senior White House official with direct knowledge of the meeting who was not authorized to publicly discuss the private gathering and spoke on condition of anonymity.

Allies argued that a leadership change now would put the RNC at a severe disadvantage heading into the next presidential cycle because a new team would need time to get up to speed and they warned that friction between the president and the committee’s leadership would curtail their ability to organize and raise money.

https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trumps-handpicked-party-chair-faces-a-rebellion-as-midterm-losses-challenge-presidents-grip-on-gop


Maybe you Republicans should think about this.

  • Trump is a loser.
  • He surrounds himself with losers.
  • He is stealing the Republican party blind.
  • He is pissing off the rest of the country.
  • He’s in it for himself.  Period.  NOT for you.

So maybe it’s time to call his bluff and get back to the real Republican Party — you know — Main Street businesses; limited government; Richard Nixon’s proposal for national health insurance; Republican support for civil rights; 92% top tax rate as Eisenhower had.

Let’s dissect his threat.

Trump threatened to punish the RNC if members crossed him and said he would refuse to help the organization, including appearing at fundraisers or allowing his name and image to be used in mail and digital solicitations.

“refuse to help the organization.”  He really helped on Nov 3, right?

He will not appear at fundraisers.  Big fucking deal.  His crowds from 2016 and 2020 are gone and are not coming back.  He plays to mostly empty venues.

Will not allow his name or image to be used.  Who needs a fat old man, with makeup, who stumbles along, can’t keep a train of thought, sleeps through meetings . . .

 

It’s not coincidence

Let’s be clear about something: This Huang-Invidia business is NOT an espionage case. It’s business as usual for Trump, his capos, and the rest of the Trump mob family.

There was no “honeypot.”

There was no entrapment of an innocent old guy who can’t keep his pants zipped.

It was collusion at the highest levels.

Jensen Huang and Alice Huang worked together to evade export controls.

They worked with Lutnick to evade export controls.

Jensen Huang traveled to China WITH TRUMP ON BOARD AF-1.

It’s not a coincidence that Lutnick’s sons have $362 million invested in Invidia.

It’s not coincidence that Lutnick has pushed to loosen export rules that affect his family’s businesses and investments.

It’s not coincidence that Trumo likes to wet his beak — Invidia put $25 million into Trump’s ballroom

Ian Fleiming, author of the James Bond novels and a lifelong British intell officer summed it up: “Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. Three times is enemy action.”

Meanwhile, Trump is headed for China this week where he will meet with Putin to (1) turn over Ukraine to Russia and (2) sabotage NATO. Meanwhile, Trump will (1) clear Xi to import all the Invidia chips he wants while (2) he stabs Taiwan in the back.

 

Fiction becomes reality

If anyone had written a book that a man like Hegseth would be put in charge of our military, that a man like RFK Jr. would be in charge of our health system, and a man like Kash Patel in charge of the FBI it would have been ridiculed as way too far-fetched and no publisher would have touched it.

But here we are.

Sean Duffy, Secretary of Transportation, and his son-in-law and the FAA

This is Sean Duffy’s son-in-law, Michael Alfonso.

Image

Sean Duffy is the unqualified and incompetent “reality TV” star who is now Secretary of Transportation; his daughter is married to Michael Alfonso.

Alfonso is the representative-elect of Wisconsin’s 7th Congressional district. A member of the Republican Party, he was the Republican nominee for the district in 2026; he won.

Alfonso ran for Congress.  Guess who paid for his campaign?

Pay attention: An AI startup, Air Space Intelligence Inc, gave a pile of money to Alfonso’s Congressional campaign.

Then Sean Duffy and the FAA gave that company a 12 year, $875M contract for their AI air traffic control system.