How did we get here? Start with Reagan.

How did we get to the point where an unforced error — it wasn’t weather, it wasn’t a terrorist attack, it was simple incompetence — could inflict so much damage on a rich, technologically advanced nation? To use the old line: Gradually, then suddenly.

According to federal officials, the immediate cause of the problem was a failed router upgrade at a remote radio facility in Arkansas, combined with a so far unexplained issue at a radar facility in Amarillo, Texas. So far there is no specific reason to doubt this story, just the fact that Trump officials lie about everything. But in any case, the real question is not the specifics of what happened Friday but how a basic federal function like air traffic control could have deteriorated to the point where minor, local problems could bring the whole system crashing down.

Remarkably, the sudden disruption of air travel was a disaster foretold. Just two months before the ground stop, the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office warned that the ongoing effort to modernize air traffic control was a rush job that was all too likely to go wrong…

And sure enough …

…But why are the FAA’s systems so outdated? And I mean outdated: The agency is planning to phase out floppy disks by 2028.

The answer is that the FAA isn’t unusual. In the U.S., government at all levels — federal, state and local — runs on outdated software and hardware, with legacy systems basically held together with paper clips and rubber bands. During the Covid crisis, as states scrambled to provide temporarily enhanced unemployment benefits, we learned that many states were still administering benefits using systems running on COBOL, a programming language introduced in 1959.

This reliance on antiquated technology isn’t because government workers are stupid. It’s because for many decades they haven’t been given the resources to upgrade their equipment. America used to have a government that invested in the future. But ever since Ronald Reagan declared that “…government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem”, critical government functions have been starved of funds for investment…

…And then came DOGE. DOGE utterly failed in its promise to reduce federal costs by trillions of dollars and, in fact, it almost surely worsened the budget deficit by, among other things, slashing the number of IRS auditorsand hence undermining tax collection. Elon Musk and his gang of twentysomething vandals did, however,manage to fire or drive out an astonishing 13 percent of the federal work force in a matter of months.

These drastic job cuts weren’t based on careful evaluation of which jobs could safely be eliminated, based on consultation with experts who actually knew how government agencies worked. Instead, the Muskovites came in with an attitude of arrogant ignorance: They knew nothing about the agencies of which they became temporary overlords, but believed themselves to be so much smarter than the people working at those agencies that they didn’t need to check with those people before wielding their chainsaws.

In the end, they disrupted many essential government functions, and in some cases agencies scrambled to rehire the workers who had been laid off.

Did DOGE help cause the air travel disaster? My guess is that we’ll eventually find out that it did, but we’re just beginning to piece together exactly what happened.

What’s already clear, however, is that DOGE’s attitude of arrogant ignorance was central to the FAA modernization program. That GAO report makes it clear that there were strong reasons to worry that the program was being rushed without adequate thought or consultation. It’s also clear that Duffy and his subordinates ignored these warnings, presumably believing that whoever was advising them was smarter than all those timid experts and bureaucrats — those who had survived the DOGE cuts.

The idea that a random rich guy and some twentysomething incels could blunder in and immediately eliminate the fraudwasteandabuse they assumed comprises most government spending with no relevant expertise was both incredibly damaging in itself and reflects much deeper Republican ideas about government, ones that Trump himself was unhinged enough to fully implement. Underfund infrastructure and fire essential employees with no process, and days like Friday are going to keep coming across many sectors.